No, your customers don't have to re-sign direct debit if you leave GoCardless, as long as the mandates move through the Bacs bulk change process. The instruction each customer gave their own bank is transferred to your new provider, and they're told about the change by email rather than sent a form to fill in. With Adfin, 10 or more mandates move this way; with fewer than 10, customers sign a new Adfin mandate online.
In this article
The short version
- Customers don't re-sign if your mandates move through the Bacs bulk change process.
- Adfin moves 10 or more mandates this way; under 10, customers sign a new mandate online.
- The change date is at least five weeks out, and Adfin emails your customers on that day in your branding.
- Stop new GoCardless collections about a week before and plan every collection due around the change date.
- Xero and QuickBooks users switch the payment option on their invoices so nothing is collected twice.
Why your customers don't need to sign again
It's easy to picture your mandates as a list sitting inside GoCardless that you either take with you or lose. A mandate is really an instruction your customer gave their own bank, allowing a named organisation to collect from their account. Their bank holds it. It points at GoCardless only because GoCardless runs your collections.
A Bacs bulk change repoints that instruction. Both providers and their sponsoring banks agree a change date, and from that date your customer's bank accepts collections from your new provider under the instruction it already holds. Nobody re-enters bank details, and nobody signs anything.
GoCardless's own terms commit it to helping you move to another provider when you leave: it enters into a bulk change deed and, once its sponsor bank approves the transfer, hands over a list of your customers and their mandate details. Its help centre says it won't cancel any mandates or close your account until the bulk change has been authorised and completed.
Bacs doesn't set a minimum number of mandates for a bulk change, so each provider sets its own. Adfin moves 10 or more mandates this way. With fewer than 10, customers sign a new mandate online, which is quicker than waiting weeks for two banks.
What you and your customers see
For you, a GoCardless direct debit migration to Adfin starts in Adfin's payment settings. You request the migration and choose a change date, which has to be a working day at least five weeks away. Adfin submits the bulk change request and arranges the bulk change deed and the notice of change with GoCardless. You're copied on the messages, but there's nothing to sign or send.
Your part is tidying up first. Adfin needs your account verified, Xero or QuickBooks connected and your customers imported, so it can match each mandate to the right customer. On GoCardless, cancel duplicate mandates and ones for former clients, and check every remaining mandate has the account holder's name, email and address, because mandates missing those details can't be moved.
Your customers don't have to do anything. Adfin emails each of them on the change date, in your branding, as Bacs requires. You can send a personal heads-up beforehand if you'd like to, and it's a good place to tell them the name they'll see on their bank statement, since a customer who doesn't recognise a new name may cancel the debit at their bank. If you're planning a price rise too, send that separately with its own advance notice.
The Direct Debit Guarantee carries on as before. Your customers keep their right to advance notice of each collection, to a full and immediate refund from their bank if a payment is taken in error, and to cancel at any time through their bank.
A worked timeline
Here's how the weeks run for a typical move of more than 10 mandates from GoCardless to Adfin.
| When | What happens | What you do |
|---|---|---|
| Five weeks or more before the change date | You request the migration in Adfin and pick the change date. Adfin submits the bulk change request to GoCardless. | Finish Adfin verification, connect Xero or QuickBooks, import customers and clean up mandates on GoCardless. |
| The weeks in between | GoCardless and both sponsor banks approve the change. GoCardless puts this at three to five weeks for Bacs. | Brief your team. Don't raise Adfin invoices for customers who are moving yet. |
| About a week before | GoCardless shares your mandate data with Adfin and usually stops taking new mandates. | Stop creating new GoCardless collections, as GoCardless advises 5 to 7 days before. Decide which provider takes each collection due around the change date. |
| Change date | Mandates appear in Adfin, usually late in the afternoon, and are cancelled on GoCardless. Adfin emails your customers in your branding. | Complete the migration review: approve suggested matches and link any unmatched mandates to customers. |
| Activation date, three working days later | Adfin can start collecting. The gap is a Bacs requirement. | Check repeating invoices are set to collect through Adfin and run a small first batch. |
| Around five working days after the change date | GoCardless closes the account once every mandate has moved, unless you ask it to keep it open. | Export payment history and payout reports before then. |
Scheduled payments and the change date
Anything GoCardless has already submitted still collects, unless the customer's bank fails it, and reaches you in a GoCardless payout with its fee taken off. GoCardless doesn't stop or take over your subscriptions, so it's up to you to cancel them on GoCardless and set them up again in Adfin.
The customers to plan for are the ones whose collection falls between the pause and the activation date. Two things can go wrong: a customer is missed for the month, or they're charged twice because a last GoCardless collection and a first Adfin collection both go out for the same invoice. Before the pause starts, list every collection due in that window and decide, customer by customer, which side takes it.
Say a customer's £850 retainer normally collects on the 12th, your change date is the 15th and Adfin can collect from the 18th. The 12th falls inside the pause, so you either raise it on GoCardless a few days early, before the pause begins, or let Adfin collect it from the 18th, with advance notice of the new date. Note the choice against the customer.
If a final GoCardless collection fails, GoCardless still charges its fee on it, because it charges on every submitted payment. Once the mandate has moved, Adfin collects the amount instead. Adfin doesn't charge for a failed direct debit and retries it for free.
If you use Xero or QuickBooks
Double collection during a move tends to happen where your accounting software is still set up to collect through GoCardless. Before the change date:
- In Xero, remove GoCardless as a payment service on the invoice branding themes your moving customers use, so new invoices don't offer it.
- In QuickBooks, turn off GoCardless under Charge direct debit on recurring invoices for those customers.
- If you opt in to automatic invoice migration, repeating invoices linked to Adfin in Xero or QuickBooks switch to Adfin collection on the activation date. Schedules that live only in GoCardless, such as subscriptions, have to be recreated in Adfin.
- Switch off any integration that posts GoCardless payouts into Xero or QuickBooks once the last GoCardless payout has landed, so payments aren't recorded twice.
From the activation date, payments taken through Adfin are marked paid in Xero or QuickBooks automatically, and payouts arrive in full every weekday. If an invoice slips during the move, Adfin's collection agents follow it up over email, SMS or WhatsApp within the rules you approve.
Related guides
- Switching payment provider: a complete guide
- Running two payment providers while you switch
- What to tell clients before you switch direct debit provider (with template wording)
- How to migrate GoCardless direct debit mandates without asking clients to re-sign
- Switching direct debit provider: what actually happens to your mandates
Common questions
Do my customers have to re-sign direct debit if I leave GoCardless? Not if the mandates move through the Bacs bulk change process. Adfin uses it for 10 or more mandates, and your customers keep paying under the instruction they already gave their bank; with fewer than 10, they sign a new mandate online.
How many mandates do I need for a bulk change? Bacs sets no minimum, so it's up to each provider. Adfin moves 10 or more mandates through the bulk change; with fewer than 10, customers sign a new Adfin mandate online.
Will GoCardless co-operate with a bulk change? Its terms commit it to entering into a bulk change deed and passing your customers' mandate details to the new provider once its sponsor bank approves, and it doesn't cancel mandates until the change is complete.
How long does a GoCardless direct debit migration take? GoCardless puts a Bacs bulk change at three to five weeks, which is why Adfin sets the change date at least five weeks out. Adfin can collect from three working days after the change date.
Who tells my customers about the move? Adfin emails your customers on the change date, in your branding, as Bacs requires. They don't need to do anything, and you can send a personal note beforehand if you'd like to.
Does my payment history move with the mandates? No. Only the mandate details move, so export your history before GoCardless closes the account and set up your recurring schedules again in Adfin.
Sources
- Bacs - The little Bacs guide to switching facilities management provider (accurate as of November 2026) https://www.bacs.co.uk/media/xglbtzor/little_bacs_guide_to_switching_fm_providers.pdf
- Pay.UK - The Direct Debit Guarantee (accurate as of November 2026) https://www.directdebit.co.uk/direct-debit-explained/direct-debit-guarantee/
- Adfin Help Centre - Bulk-migrate your direct debit mandates to Adfin (10+ mandates) (accurate as of November 2026) https://support.adfin.com/en/articles/12688044-how-to-migrate-direct-debit-mandates-to-adfin
- GoCardless Support Centre - Bulk changing away from GoCardless (accurate as of November 2026) https://support.gocardless.com/hc/en-gb/articles/115005800129-Bulk-changing-away-from-GoCardless
- GoCardless - Bank Debit Terms (accurate as of November 2026) https://gocardless.com/legal/bank-debit-terms
- Xero - Online invoice payments (accurate as of November 2026) https://www.xero.com/uk/campaign/online-invoice-payments/
- QuickBooks - Get started with GoCardless in QuickBooks Online (accurate as of November 2026) https://quickbooks.intuit.com/learn-support/en-uk/help-article/recurring-payments/get-started-gocardless/L1cd2payL_GB_en_GB
