Alternatives
5 min read
November 20, 2026

Adfin vs alternatives: direct debit, pay by bank and card fees compared

Adfin team
Adfin team

Many UK businesses use two providers to get paid: GoCardless for direct debit and a card provider such as Stripe. Adfin and GoCardless Standard both charge 1% + 20p on a direct debit, with a cap, and Adfin charges 20p + 1% on a standard UK card against Stripe's 1.5% + 20p. The rest of the difference is in failed payments, disputes and running everything from one account.

In this article

The short version

  • GoCardless doesn't take cards, so many businesses run a second provider for card payments.
  • Adfin charges 20p + 1% on a standard UK card, against Stripe's 1.5% + 20p.
  • A £1,500 invoice costs £15.20 by standard card with Adfin, or £4.20 by pay by bank.
  • Adfin charges nothing for failed direct debits and retries them free.
  • Adfin is pounds only, so businesses billing in other currencies need another provider.

The fees side by side

If you take both direct debit and cards today, you're probably paying two sets of fees on two accounts. GoCardless doesn't take card payments, so card payers go through a second provider. The table sets the published UK prices for each method side by side.

Adfin and GoCardless both add a charge on direct debits above £2,000. Neither Adfin nor GoCardless Standard has a monthly fee, and Adfin has no minimum contract.

What it costs on real payments

A small direct debit costs the same with either, and the gap opens up once cards and larger invoices come in. Using the published rates:

  • A £40 monthly subscription collected by direct debit costs 60p with Adfin and 60p with GoCardless Standard.
  • A £1,500 invoice paid with a standard UK card costs £15.20 with Adfin and £22.70 with Stripe. Paid with a business card, it's £30.20 with Adfin against £42.20 at Stripe's premium UK card rate. Paid by pay by bank or direct debit through Adfin, it's £4.20.
  • An £8,000 invoice paid with a standard UK card costs £80.20 with Adfin and £120.20 with Stripe. Paid by pay by bank through Adfin, it's still £4.20, because the percentage is capped at £4.

Most of the saving on larger invoices tends to come from moving them off cards and onto a capped method. With Adfin you can send one payment link that offers card, Apple Pay, Google Pay and pay by bank, so the client chooses, and on a business-to-business invoice you can pass business and international card fees on to the payer as a surcharge.

Failed payments, disputes and payouts

GoCardless charges its fee on every direct debit you submit, whether it succeeds or not. Adfin charges only for successful payments, and retries a failed direct debit at no cost. You can also switch on charging a saved card or sending a payment link if the retries don't work.

Adfin pays out every weekday, gross, with its fees invoiced separately, so the amount that lands matches what your customers paid. Pay by bank arrives the same day, cards and bank transfers two working days later, and direct debits within three working days of the collection date. Stripe's default payout schedule for UK cards is three business days, with a longer wait on your first payout.

What the headline rates leave out

A per-payment comparison misses the work around the payments. With two providers, you've got two dashboards, two sets of payouts to match in Xero or QuickBooks, and GoCardless retries failed direct debits but doesn't follow up unpaid invoices, so that stays with you or a separate tool.

Adfin puts direct debit, cards, pay by bank and bank transfer on one account, marks invoices paid in Xero or QuickBooks, and includes essential credit control at no extra cost: unlimited reminders by email, SMS and WhatsApp, and statements. Enhanced credit control, at 0.3% per paid invoice and only when it's used, adds collection agents that adjust the timing, channel and tone of chasing within rules you approve, and reminders sent from your own email address.

Before you compare, add up a typical month of your own payments by method and size. If most of your income is small direct debits, the prices are close. If you take a lot of card payments or larger invoices, the difference tends to be bigger.

Related guides

Common questions

How does Adfin's direct debit pricing compare with GoCardless? Both charge 1% + 20p per direct debit, with a cap. GoCardless charges on failed submissions too, while Adfin charges only for successful payments and retries failures for free.

Does GoCardless take card payments? No. GoCardless is a bank payment provider, so businesses that want card payments add a second provider alongside it.

How much does Adfin charge for card payments? 20p + 1% for a standard UK card, 20p + 2% for premium cards including business and EEA cards, and 20p + 3% for cards issued outside the EEA.

What does a £1,500 invoice cost to collect? With Adfin, £15.20 by standard UK card or £4.20 by pay by bank or direct debit. At Stripe's standard UK card rate it's £22.70.

Can Adfin take payments in other currencies? No. Adfin collects in pounds only. If you bill in other currencies, GoCardless or Stripe can handle that.

Are there monthly fees with Adfin? No. There's no monthly fee, minimum or contract. You pay per successful payment, plus enhanced credit control when you use it.

Sources

  • Adfin - Pricing (accurate as of November 2026) https://www.adfin.com/pricing
  • GoCardless - Pricing (accurate as of November 2026) https://gocardless.com/pricing/
  • GoCardless - Transaction fees on submitted payments (accurate as of November 2026) https://support.gocardless.com/hc/en-gb/articles/115002831125
  • Stripe - UK pricing (accurate as of November 2026) https://stripe.com/gb/pricing
  • Stripe - Payouts (accurate as of November 2026) https://docs.stripe.com/payouts
Adfin team
Adfin team